One of the most common questions that gemologists are asked is how to tell the difference between a real diamond and a fake stone.
We spoke with Marcel Kaminstein, a jewelry expert with years of experience running specialty luxury jewelry retail programs at LVMH the worlds largest luxury retailer and president of online retailer IfULoveMe, about how to tell when a diamond is real, and when and why to take it to an expert.
Test At Home
“We see a lot of estate jewelry that comes up in our line of business,” Kaminstein explained to the NY Times. “People who are selling their parents’ estate assume the money is in the house itself — but sometimes the things inside the home have a lot more value than they think.”
For jewelry you inherit or find at garage sales, it’s best to do a few simple DIY tests before bringing the pieces in for a gemologist to look at.
1. Look at the diamond and setting through a loupe.
A loupe is a magnifying glass that you can buy at any jewelry store and will let you take a closer look at your gem and setting.
“When you’re looking at a diamond, there are a few things you’ll notice,” Kaminstein told us. “First, the majority of diamonds are made in nature so that means you’re going to see some imperfections in the carbon. A fake stone would be perfect — absolutely perfect.”
Kaminstein cautions that certain lab-grown stones will also look perfect through the loupe, and so you should be cautious before discarding perfect gems. It can be a clue, however, to take a closer look or bring the stone to an expert.
Second, observe the diamond’s edges. “When you’re taking a look at a diamond through a loupe, a real stone is going to have sharp edges, and a fake stone will have rounded edges,” Kaminstein explained.
Lastly, look at the mounting and etchings, especially any marks that signify what metal was used. “If the metal is gold plated or silver, chances are it’s not a diamond because why would you put a nice stone mounted in such a cheap metal?” Kaminstein said. “Most diamonds are mounted in gold or set in platinum.”
“Also take a look at the mounting itself and how that diamond is set,” she added. “If the setting looks like it’s of poor quality, that probably means it’s not going to be a real diamond either.”
2. Rub sandpaper against the stone.
This is an easy test since diamonds are one of the world’s hardest materials and won’t be scratched by the rough surface. “If it’s a diamond, it will remain perfect, if it’s a cubic zirconium, it will scratch it up,” Kaminstein said.
3. Do the fog test.
Breathe hot air on your diamond the same way you would if you were fogging up a bathroom mirror.
“A fake diamond will fog up for a short period of time whereas a real diamond will not because it won’t retain the heat,” Kaminstein explained.
4. Hold it in the light to see how it sparkles.
The way that diamonds reflect light is unique: Inside the stone, the diamond will sparkle gray and white (known as “brilliance”) while outside of the gem, it will reflect rainbow colors onto other surfaces (this dispersed light is known as “fire”).
A fake diamond will have rainbow colors that you can see inside the diamond.
“People have a misconception that diamonds sparkle like a rainbow, but they don’t,” Kaminstein said. “They do sparkle, but it’s more of a gray color. If you see something with rainbow colors [inside the stone], it could be a sign that it’s not a diamond.”
Still confused? This is a good explainer of brilliance versus fire.
5. Look at the stone’s refractivity.
Diamonds are so sparkly because of the way they refract and bend light. Glass, quartz, and cubic zirconium may mimic a diamond’s brilliance, but they have much lower refractive indexes.
This means that if your stone isn’t in a setting, you can place it over a newspaper and the light will scatter inside the real diamond and prevent a black reflection. A fake diamond will let the black shine through, and you may even be able to read a word depending on the size of the fake stone.
If your diamond is mounted, make sure you can’t see through it to the mount itself — that’s a very bad sign.
Test With A Gemologist
Once you’ve done all your home tests, it’s time to take your jewels that could be diamonds to a gemologist.
“You don’t want to take a box full of jewelry because it will cost you money for them to look,” Kaminstein explained. “I would be flat out frank and say you’re not interested in selling, but just ask if they’re worth you paying attention to or if it’s fine to let the kid’s play with them.”
But don’t just take your diamonds to any old jeweler. It’s important to do your research and find a qualified gemologist.
“At mall stores, they tend to have sales people — not gemologists,” Kaminstein said. “They just know what sells in their stores and what appeals to the masses. Look beyond the average jewelry store and go to a local antique stores or ask your local antique jewelry store who is a reputable gemologist in town who knows about diamonds.”
Even if you know the jewelry you have contains diamonds, it can pay off to take them to a gemologist to know how much they’re actually worth.
“Say you have five, 1-carat diamonds on the table — the cut, color, and clarity will be a huge factor in why one is worth $800 and one is worth $10,000,” he said.
What it could be instead of a diamond:
White topaz — Topaz is a mineral that is usually tinted yellow, red, brown, or pale gray, but can sometimes be white or appear colorless. Diamonds are much harder than topaz, however, which can wear down and scratch over time making it dull or cloudy.
White sapphire — We usually think of sapphires as being blue, but this gem can also be white. Just like topaz, sapphires are prone to more damage than diamonds and do not have the same fire and brilliance of a true diamond.
Cubic zirconium — Mass-produced since 1976, cubic zirconium scratches easily and does not have the same fire and shine as diamonds.
Moissanite — Moissanite is harder than cubic zirconium and these stones are visually dazzling. The main difference is that moissanites have a different brilliance than a diamond where you can see rainbow colors within the stone, giving it a disco ball effect.
Lab grown — Lab-grown diamonds are technically “real” diamonds both chemically and physical, but they will not fetch for the same price as a mined diamond. Hirsch says they usually sell for about 20% to 30% less than a traditional diamond.
So the next time you run across something you think is just cheap costume jewelry, it’s important to test it — just in case.
Share this post
- Tags: diamonds, fake diamonds, ifuloveme, Jewelry, LVMH, Marcel Kaminstein, online jewelry, real diamonds, real vs fake, spot a fake